Almost every importer ticks the insurance box. Very few read the clause set behind it, and that is where the money quietly goes missing.
I have sat in on claims meetings where a buyer lost a five-figure shipment and discovered, in the same conversation, that the policy covered a list of named perils and seawater ingress from a hatch cover was not on it. The premium was paid; the claim still failed.
This guide covers the parts that decide outcomes: the clause level you are buying, who insures at each stage, how much to insure, and what to collect at the scene so a claim survives contact with a loss adjuster.
The distinction that costs people their claim
Two different products are sold as "insurance" at the booking stage, and buyers routinely confuse them.
Cargo insurance covers your goods. It responds when cargo is lost or damaged by a covered peril and pays the insured value.
Forwarder liability cover covers the forwarder. It responds only when the forwarder is legally liable, and the limit is normally calculated per kilo of gross weight rather than per unit of value — on lightweight, high-value cargo that cap can be a small fraction of what you paid.
When a booking screen offers "add insurance" for a small fixed fee, ask in writing: is this cargo cover on my goods at invoice value, or the forwarder's liability cover? The answer decides what happens after a casualty.
| Scenario | Cargo insurance pays? | Forwarder liability pays? |
|---|---|---|
| Container lost overboard in heavy weather | Yes, if your clause level covers the peril | Usually no — peril-of-the-sea defences |
| Cartons crushed by bad stowage at the forwarder's CFS | Yes, as damage in transit | Possibly, capped by weight not value |
| Water damage because your carton spec was too light for a sea voyage | No — insufficient packing exclusion | No |
| Goods stolen from a destination warehouse before collection | Only if the policy still covers that stage | No |
| Ship arrested, six-week delay, season missed | No — delay and loss of market excluded | No |
Who is supposed to insure: read your Incoterms first
Insurance responsibility follows the risk transfer point, not the invoice. Get it wrong and you can end up with a gap of a few hours that happens to be exactly when the truck rolls over.
| Term | Risk passes to buyer | Who insures | The trap |
|---|---|---|---|
| EXW | At the seller's premises | Buyer, from the factory gate | Cover must start before goods leave the factory. Most buyers insure only from the port. |
| FOB | Goods on board at origin port | Buyer | Inland China trucking is the seller's risk, but sellers rarely carry real cover. If their truck burns, you may have no recovery route. |
| CFR | Goods on board | Buyer | Same inland gap as FOB, and nobody has arranged marine cover unless you did. |
| CIF | Goods on board | Seller arranges, buyer benefits | Seller buys the minimum the rules require — the narrowest cover level. You are insured, barely. |
| CIP | Handed to first carrier | Seller arranges, buyer benefits | Broader than CIF, but still the seller's choice of insurer and deductible. |
| DDP / DAP | At destination | Seller | You are not the insured party. Claim against the seller, not an insurer — and confirm their cover is adequate. |
Under the current Incoterms rules, CIF obliges the seller to insure for at least 110% of contract value at the minimum cover level, while CIP requires a broader level. The rules only set a floor, so confirm the exact wording in the official Incoterms text and in your contract — a seller can buy better cover if you ask.
If you are buying FOB or CFR, the fix is a policy that starts at the supplier's door, not at the port. Ask for origin inland cover explicitly; it is not automatic.
The three cover levels, and when each is enough
Most marine cargo policies in international trade are written on the London Institute Cargo Clauses, in three grades. The letters are not marketing tiers — they are different legal structures.
| Level | How it works | What it responds to | Reasonable for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clause C | Named perils only. If the cause of loss is not on the list, there is no claim. | Fire, explosion, stranding, grounding, collision, discharge at a port of distress, general average sacrifice. | Low-value, robust, non-perishable cargo where tail risk matters less than premium. |
| Clause B | Named perils, longer list than C. | Everything in C plus earthquake, volcanic eruption, lightning, washing overboard, water entering the container or hold. | General manufactured goods where the realistic loss is water ingress or a handling accident. |
| Clause A | All risks subject to a defined exclusion list. The burden shifts: the insurer must show an exclusion applies. | Any accidental loss or damage from an external cause unless excluded. | Consumer goods, electronics, retail packaging — anything where partial damage is plausible. |
Here is the trap in practice. A container that arrives with a forklift puncture through forty cartons is probably not a claim under Clause C. Under Clause A, it is. The premium difference is small against the value at stake; the difference in outcomes is not.
For Amazon FBA sellers and DTC brands shipping retail-ready packaging, Clause A is close to mandatory. For a container of garden hose fittings, Clause C may genuinely be enough. Be deliberate, because the cover that arrives with a default CIF shipment is the narrow end.
What no standard policy pays for
These exclusions appear in almost every wording. Knowing them stops you buying insurance as a substitute for operational work.
- Insufficient or unsuitable packing. If cartons collapse in a stack or inner packaging cannot survive condensation, the loss is your defect, not a transit peril. This is the most common denial I see on containerised consumer goods.
- Inherent vice. Goods that deteriorate from their own nature — moisture-sensitive products, foodstuffs, batteries — are not covered for that deterioration.
- Delay and loss of market. A late container is a commercial loss, not a physical one. Nobody insures your missed Black Friday.
- Insufficient documentation. No clean origin documents and no evidence of condition at handover makes a claim unprovable, which for practical purposes means unpaid.
- Wilful misconduct and undeclared cargo. Ship what you did not declare, or what the policy excludes by category, and you have bought nothing.
The add-ons that actually earn their premium
| Extension | Why it matters in the China trade |
|---|---|
| War and strikes | Standard clauses exclude both, and they are not theoretical on Red Sea and Middle East routings. Normally a separate buy, priced separately, withdrawable at short notice. |
| Warehouse to warehouse | Extends cover from the supplier's premises to your final warehouse, including inland legs. Without it you have port-to-port cover and two uninsured truck journeys. |
| Seller's contingency | Protects you when you rely on someone else's policy — the CIF seller, a trading company, an agent — and their cover turns out void, under-insured, or refused. |
| Temperature and humidity | For candles, cosmetics, adhesives, anything with a melting point or moisture spec. Standard cover does not respond to heat damage on a quay. |
| Deck cargo cover | Standard underdeck wordings will not respond to on-deck stowage. Confirm deck stowage is either prohibited in your booking or insured. |
Insuring the right number
Under-insurance is the quiet killer, because of how the average clause works. Insure a shipment for two-thirds of its value, lose half of it, and you are not paid for half — you are paid for half, reduced by the same two-thirds ratio, minus the deductible.
The insured value is not the FOB price on the supplier's invoice. Build it up like this:
| Component | Include? | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Goods value (invoice / FOB) | Yes | Base. Use the price you actually paid, including tooling amortised into the unit price. |
| International freight | Yes | Belongs in insured value if prepaid or bundled into a DDP-style price. |
| Duty and import taxes | Often | Check the wording — some policies include duty, others need an extension. |
| Expected margin | Yes, via the 110% uplift | Insurance at 110% of CIF value stops a total loss from wiping out profit and overhead too. |
| Tooling, moulds, development costs | If they travel with the goods | Easy to forget, expensive to lose. |
Then apply the rate: premium is quoted per thousand of insured value, so insured value × rate ÷ 1000. Get the rate and the per-claim deductible in writing.
General average: the scenario nobody budgets for
If the carrier sacrifices cargo or incurs extraordinary expense to save the ship — jettisoning containers, diverting to a port of refuge, salvage — the loss is shared proportionally among all cargo owners. Your container can arrive perfect and still be held, because the carrier will not release cargo until your share of the contribution is secured.
This is routine in major casualties, not history. Your policy should cover general average contributions and salvage charges; confirm it in writing. And when your forwarder emails about a general average declaration, treat it as urgent. Buyers who ignore the first notice find their cargo accruing port storage while they argue about who should have told them.
The claim process, step by step
- Preserve the evidence before you touch anything. Photograph the container number, the seal, the door, the damaged cartons in place, and where the damage sat in the stow. Once the container is devanned and the cartons are in a pile, you cannot prove where the damage came from.
- Notify in writing, same day. Carrier, forwarder, and insurer. Policies and carriage conventions carry short notification windows, and late notice is an argument you do not want.
- Request a joint survey. The insurer appoints a local surveyor at destination, and their report carries far more weight than your photos. Do not repair, rework, or scrap the goods before the survey unless they are a hazard.
- Quantify the loss. Separate damaged from undamaged, count units, get a repair estimate. On a partial loss the claim is the depreciation in value, not the full invoice.
- Send the claim with the full pack. Insurers assess on documents. Missing items trigger a request for more information, which costs weeks.
- Handle subrogation. Once the insurer pays, they take over your rights against the carrier and will want a letter of subrogation. It does not reduce your recovery.
- Watch the time bar. Limitation periods are shorter than most people expect. Diary the claim date and chase — an unanswered claim is not a frozen claim.
The documentation that decides the claim
| Document | What it proves | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Original bill of lading or sea waybill | That you had insurable interest and the goods were carried | Carrier / forwarder |
| Commercial invoice and packing list | Insured value and exactly what was in each carton | Supplier |
| Pre-shipment inspection report with photos, plus container and seal photos at origin | Condition of the goods when loaded, and that the container left sound and sealed — your baseline | QC provider / loading supervisor |
| Delivery receipt with remarks | That you noted the damage at handover, not a week later | Trucker / warehouse |
| Survey report | Independent assessment of cause and extent | Insurer's appointed surveyor |
| Repair, rework, or replacement quotations, plus carrier correspondence | The financial quantification, and that you preserved your rights on time | Your vendors and files |
Note what those rows have in common: they are created before the ship sails. A claim is an evidence exercise that starts at the factory, which is why the inspection you commission for quality purposes doubles as the foundation of any claim. If you are not running one, read the guide to factory inspection in China.
Six reasons claims get rejected
- The clause level did not cover the peril. Water damage on a Clause C policy is the classic.
- Packing was judged inadequate. Double-wall cartons, corner protection, moisture barriers are underwriting facts, not cosmetics.
- Under-insurance triggered the average clause, turning a valid claim into a partial payment.
- Late notice, or damage found after the goods were signed for clean and moved.
- The insured party was wrong. If the policy names the supplier or forwarder as assured and you suffer the loss, insurable interest becomes a fight.
- No proof of pre-shipment condition. Without a baseline, the insurer can reasonably conclude the damage predated loading.
Buying it: three routes and what each is good for
| Route | Strength | Weakness |
|---|---|---|
| Forwarder's cargo product | Fast, in the booking flow, priced per shipment | You often do not see the wording until after the loss. Confirm clause level and assured before ticking the box. |
| Independent broker, open cover | One policy for the year, negotiated clause level, a named contact when things go wrong | Requires declaration discipline — undisclosed shipments are not covered. |
| Marketplace policy | Cheap and instant for small parcels | Built for many small shipments; thin against single-container exposures. |
If you ship more than a couple of containers a year, open cover with a broker is usually better: it moves the decision out of a thirty-second booking screen into a policy you have actually read. See the guide to vetting a freight forwarder in China, then talk to a broker who writes cargo — not to the person selling you the freight.
How insurance fits with the rest of your risk stack
Cargo cover does not cover the product's behaviour in the market. Product liability responds when your product injures someone or damages property — a separate policy, increasingly required by platforms and large buyers; see the product liability and recall risk guide. Warehouse cover responds once goods sit in your own or a third-party facility, because cargo cover typically ends at the final warehouse named in the policy — Amazon's insurance does not cover your inventory. And if you sell on terms you do not fully control, check the Incoterms breakdown for where risk actually changes hands.
What I would do on the next order
Three things, all before the container is booked.
One: get the clause level in writing. Not "all risk", not "comprehensive" — the clause designation and the exclusion list. If a seller or forwarder cannot name the clause set, that is your answer about the cover.
Two: insure the full landed value at 110%, and check the deductible against the value of a single carton. A deductible larger than the typical damage on your product means the policy will never pay a partial-loss claim.
Three: build the evidence habit — container and seal photos at loading, a pre-shipment inspection report, and a delivery receipt annotated when something looks wrong. It costs almost nothing and it separates a paid claim from a story you tell at conferences.
The Bottom Line
Cargo insurance is not a checkbox and not a substitute for packing discipline. Its value is decided by three things you control before the ship sails: the clause level, the insured value, and the evidence you create at origin. Get those right and the policy does what you paid for. Get one wrong and you will find out at the worst possible moment.
Get the sourcing paperwork right the first time
The free mini-guide covers the documents, inspection checkpoints, and cost build-up that decide whether an order arrives profitable — including the checks most first-time importers skip.
Browse the China sourcing guides